Fair Pay & Worker Respect
30
Mining is a high-risk industry for labor rights and workplace safety, but the core business of mineral extraction does not inherently advance or harm fair pay and worker respect; performance depends on the company's specific operational policies and labor practices. Based on the provided evidence from First Quantum Minerals (FQM) 2024 ESG reports and news articles, the company is scored as follows: - **Collective Bargaining Share**: The 2024 ESG report states that 64% of the operating site workforce is covered by collective bargaining agreements, placing it in the 60-70% tier.
1
- **Safety Incident Rate**: FQM reported a Total Recordable Injury Frequency Rate (TRIFR) of 0.33 for 2024.
2
According to the rubric, a TRIR (equivalent to TRIFR) of approximately 0.5 corresponds to a tier of 90. One fatality was recorded at the Kansanshi mine in September 2024.
3
- **Turnover Rate**: The company reported a voluntary turnover rate of 4% in 2024.
4
While total turnover was 22% due to the suspension of Cobre Panamá, the rubric specifically measures voluntary turnover, where 4% aligns with the 70 tier.
5
- **Labor Violation Incidents**: The company faces significant legal and human rights challenges. Panama’s Supreme Court ruled its Cobre Panamá contract unconstitutional (violating 25 articles).
6
7
8
Additionally, reports from Earthworks and The Guardian document allegations of punitive measures against union members, arbitrary detentions of protesters, and health complaints from local residents.
9
10
While these involve community and state interactions, the documented 'punitive measures' against striking unions and the Supreme Court ruling suggest at least one to two significant infractions/breaches, resulting in a -30 tier.
11
- **Insecure Contract Share**: The 2024 ESG report indicates that 16% of the workforce is 'Non-ongoing' (contract/temporary), which fits the 15–20% range for the -10 tier.
12
Other KPIs such as CEO pay ratio, pay equity ratio, and specific health insurance percentages were not provided with sufficient quantitative data to score.
13
14
Fair Trade & Ethical Sourcing
-20
As a large-scale mining company, First Quantum operates in a sector with high inherent risks regarding human rights, artisanal mining encroachment, and supply chain transparency in developing regions. While the company has policies in place, the nature of mineral extraction in complex jurisdictions makes it a high-risk industry for ethical sourcing violations. First Quantum Minerals (FQM) demonstrates a strong commitment to local and indigenous procurement, though supply chain traceability and audit depth remain in developmental stages. **Supplier Diversity & Local Spend:** The company excels in this area, reporting that over 80% of its procurement spend (approximately US$2.4 billion in 2025) is directed toward nationally registered suppliers in its countries of operation.
1
2
3
It maintains extensive local business development programs, such as at the Trident mine, which supported 836 local businesses and trained 310 entrepreneurs in 2024.
4
5
**Labour Practices:** FQM reported zero substantiated incidents of forced or child labour across its global operations in 2024 and 2025.
6
7
8
It maintains a zero-tolerance policy and employs zero 'young workers' (under 18).
9
10
11
**Ethical Clauses & Audits:** The company has implemented a Supplier Code of Conduct that is mandatory for all suppliers, including audit rights and termination clauses for human rights breaches.
12
13
14
While environmental systems are audited annually, supplier labour audits are less frequent; for instance, independent labour audits were conducted for 20 contractors at Trident in 2024, and a baseline audit for Kansanshi is scheduled for Q1 2026.
15
16
17
Human rights risk reviews are conducted biannually.
18
19
20
**Traceability & Risk:** Traceability is currently limited. The company is in the process of mapping its supply chain and has identified 9 high-risk supplier categories (e.g., construction, transport, and mineral supply chains) using the Global Slavery Index.
21
22
23
While it is progressing toward Responsible Minerals Initiative (RMI) accreditation for its smelters, quantitative traceability percentages for deeper tiers (2-4) are not yet disclosed.
24
25
Honest & Fair Business
0
As a large-scale mining company, First Quantum operates in a sector with high regulatory scrutiny and complex disclosure requirements, but the core business model of mineral extraction is neutral regarding inherent honesty or fairness. The score is set to neutral, as performance on this value is determined by behavioral evidence such as regulatory compliance, transparency, and anti-corruption practices rather than the nature of the mining business itself. First Quantum Minerals (FQM) demonstrates a complex ethical profile characterized by robust corporate governance policies contrasted with significant operational and legal controversies in Panama. Regarding regulatory fines, the company has faced several penalties in the last three years, most notably a US$11 million fine for environmental damage at Cobre Panamá.
1
2
Other smaller fines include ~€469,000 in Spain (ongoing/contested) and ~AUD $18,780 in Australia.
3
The company scores poorly on the ESG Controversy Index (-100) due to the massive scale of unrest in Panama.
4
In late 2023, the Supreme Court of Panama ruled FQM’s 20-year contract unconstitutional, citing 25 legal violations, including failure to conduct public tenders.
5
6
This triggered protests involving 6% of the national population, leading to over 1,000 arrests and four deaths.
7
8
Conversely, FQM’s internal governance structures are well-documented. The board is 80% independent (8 of 10 directors), and all key committees are composed exclusively of independent directors.
9
10
The company maintains a 24/7 anonymous whistleblower hotline managed by an independent third party (Integrity Counts), with quarterly reporting to the Audit Committee.
11
12
Anti-corruption efforts are supported by a comprehensive Code of Conduct and alignment with the Extractive Sector Transparency Measures Act (ESTMA) and EITI.
13
14
Transparency and verification are strong; FQM publishes annual Tax Transparency reports and subjects its environmental management systems to regular external audits by firms like SGS Global and Knight Piésold.
15
16
17
While minor restatements occurred in 2023 regarding energy/emissions data, no material financial restatements were reported.
18
19
Audit coverage is high, with independent technical reviews of critical infrastructure like Tailings Storage Facilities (TSFs) across operations.
20
21
22
Kind to Animals
-30
Large-scale mining operations inherently involve significant land clearing and habitat destruction, which directly threatens local wildlife populations and biodiversity in the regions where the company operates. First Quantum Minerals (FQM) is scored based on its significant impact on wildlife habitats and biodiversity. Regarding 'wildlife_conservation_impact', the company is assigned a tier of -100. While FQM reports extensive conservation initiatives—including protecting 1.5 million hectares of forest,
1
investing over $8 million in fauna programs,
2
and supporting the West Lunga Ecosystem
3
—these efforts are directly contrasted by documented habitat destruction. Evidence indicates the Cobre Panamá mine destroyed over 3,000 hectares (11.6 square miles) of forest within the Donoso Protected Area,
4
a critical habitat for over 1,000 species, including the critically endangered Gemini’s dart frog and the endangered Central American spider monkey.
5
The project also disrupted the Panama Atlantic Mesoamerican Biological Corridor.
6
Because the rubric for -100 specifies 'operations have directly destroyed critical habitats with documented wildlife mortality,' the severity of the impact on an Alliance for Zero Extinction (AZE) site outweighs the reported offsets.
7
For all other KPIs, the company receives a tier of 0 (N/A). As a mining and metals firm (ISIC 0729), FQM does not engage in animal testing, animal husbandry, or the production of animal-derived consumer goods.
8
Its agricultural support programs in Zambia focus on smallholder crop production (maize, beans, chili) rather than animal agriculture.
9
There is no evidence of animal-related supply chains or testing protocols relevant to the other rubric categories.
10
11
No War, No Weapons
-10
Mining of base and precious metals is a foundational industrial activity that is not inherently linked to the arms industry, although these materials are used in a vast array of global manufacturing sectors. First Quantum Minerals (FQM) is a global mining company primarily focused on copper and nickel production.
1
Based on the provided evidence, the company does not engage in the manufacture or sale of arms, resulting in a score of 0 for revenue_arms_contracts, dual_use_technology, and board_oversight_defense.
2
3
4
Regarding human rights and conflict zones, FQM demonstrates a structured approach by aligning with the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (UNGP) and the Voluntary Principles on Security and Human Rights (VPSHR).
5
6
7
This alignment is verified through third-party human rights assessments at various mine sites (e.g., Turkey, Zambia, Panama), supporting a tier of 20 for ungp_alignment.
8
9
The company maintains robust compliance controls, screening suppliers against international sanction lists, which supports a tier of -40 for sales_embargoed_regimes.
10
However, the company faces challenges related to its historical and current operations in high-risk areas.
11
12
While FQM was moved to 'Category I (resolved)' by the UN Panel of Experts in 2003 regarding past allegations in the DRC, the evidence indicates ongoing procurement from regions with high geopolitical and security risks (e.g., Mauritania, Zambia).
13
14
Because the company does not provide a specific percentage of certified conflict-free minerals or a specific percentage for conflict-zone procurement, these are scored conservatively.
15
16
Specifically, conflict_minerals_percentage is tiered at -100 due to the lack of a stated certification percentage despite operating in mineral-rich high-risk zones.
17
18
Conflict_zone_procurement_percentage is tiered at -70 as the company acknowledges operations in high-risk jurisdictions and utilizes enhanced due diligence (VPSHR) but does not quantify the procurement volume from these areas.
19
20
Planet-Friendly Business
-40
As a large-scale mining company, First Quantum's core business involves significant land disturbance, high energy consumption, and potential for ecological degradation, which inherently conflicts with proactive environmental stewardship despite their role in supplying metals for the energy transition. First Quantum Minerals (FQM) demonstrates a complex environmental profile characterized by robust biodiversity conservation and climate risk reporting, contrasted by significant regulatory challenges and high absolute emissions. In 2024, FQM reported Scope 1 and 2 emissions of 2.43 million tCO2e and Scope 3 emissions of 1.80 million tCO2e.
1
2
While these figures represent a ~40% year-on-year decrease, the decline was primarily driven by the forced suspension of the Cobre Panamá mine and care-and-maintenance status at Ravensthorpe, rather than purely operational efficiency.
3
The company lacks a formal Net Zero target and validated SBTi targets, though it has committed to a 50% reduction in Scope 1 and 2 emissions by 2035.
4
5
FQM performs well in renewable energy, with 75% of purchased electricity sourced from renewables (primarily hydro), and has significant biodiversity programs protecting 1.5 million hectares of forest—roughly 70 times its mining footprint.
6
7
8
It also reports a 65% waste diversion rate for non-mining waste and high water reuse rates (up to 83% at Sentinel).
9
10
However, the company faces severe compliance and social challenges. In Panama, the Cobre Panamá mine was ordered to shut down following a Supreme Court ruling that declared its contract unconstitutional, amid reports of 295 environmental law violations and an $11 million fine.
11
In Zambia, the company faces legal action regarding the involuntary resettlement of thousands of residents.
12
While FQM has established 'Just Transition' frameworks and TCFD-aligned reporting (including scenario analysis for 1.5°C, 2°C, and 3°C+ pathways), these are overshadowed by active litigation and the environmental impact of its large-scale extractive operations.
13
14
15
Respect for Cultures & Communities
-40
As a large-scale mining operator, the company's core business inherently involves significant land use and potential displacement of local and indigenous communities. The company has faced major controversies, including significant community protests and legal challenges regarding the Cobre Panama mine, which led to the suspension of operations following concerns over environmental impact and community rights. First Quantum Minerals (FQM) exhibits a stark contrast between its high-level corporate reporting and significant operational conflicts, particularly in Panama and Zambia. **Community Protest & Legal Status:** The company faced a -100 tier for protest severity due to the 2023 national uprising in Panama.
1
Protests involving up to 250,000 people (6% of the population) paralyzed the country for 39 days, leading to four deaths and over 1,000 arrests.
2
3
This culminated in the Supreme Court of Panama ruling FQM's contract unconstitutional for the second time, citing 25 violations, including a lack of public consultation (FPIC bypassing).
4
5
6
**Displacement & Indigenous Rights:** In Zambia, FQM is facing legal action in English courts regarding the alleged involuntary displacement of thousands of residents at the Kansanshi and Sentinel mines.
7
Claimants allege homes were demolished without compensation or FPIC.
8
While FQM reports successful resettlements (e.g., 597 households at Trident), the ongoing litigation and community disputes over land access and loss of livelihoods warrant a -80 tier.
9
10
**Water & Environment:** Communities near Cobre Panama report mass fish deaths and health issues (skin lesions, gastrointestinal illness) linked to river pollution.
11
While FQM attributes these to unrelated bacteria, the Environmental Law Alliance identified acid mine drainage risks and inadequate monitoring, leading to a -80 for water-access harm.
12
**Economic Contributions:** Positively, FQM demonstrates industry-leading local economic engagement, with 95% local hire and over 80% local procurement ($2.265 billion in 2024).
13
14
It also has independently verified royalty payments (e.g., $375 million annual guarantee in Panama before the ruling).
15
16
17
However, these economic benefits are overshadowed by the systemic social license failures that led to the total closure of its largest asset.
18
19
Safe & Smart Tech
0
As a mining company, First Quantum Minerals does not have a core business model centered on software, AI, or data services, making the 'Safe & Smart Tech' value largely neutral to its primary operations. First Quantum Minerals (FQM) demonstrates a structured approach to cybersecurity and data governance, though many practices align with standard industrial mining expectations rather than technology leadership. Regarding data breaches, the company reports no significant breaches in the past three years, maintaining a strong preventative focus through an outsourced Security Operations Center (SOC) and third-party incident response services.
1
2
AI governance is emerging; the Board received formal education on AI applications in mining in 2025, and the Audit Committee maintains oversight of AI initiatives, including machine learning tools for blast optimization and autonomous drilling systems.
3
4
Security training is mandatory for all IT-enabled employees, including annual awareness campaigns and phishing simulations, though specific outcome metrics (like click rates) are not disclosed, leading to a neutral tier.
5
6
Authentication security includes risk-based access controls and multi-factor authentication (MFA) across key systems, which is industry-standard.
7
Vulnerability management is described as an ongoing process involving patching and prioritized remediation, supported by periodic penetration testing and independent audits.
8
User data control is addressed through a formal privacy policy (reviewed 2020) that grants users rights to data portability, erasure, and rectification, particularly for recruitment data.
9
Regulatory compliance is managed by a Group Data Protection Officer, with the company acknowledging its obligations under various international jurisdictions and preparing for the EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD).
10
11
12
While the company utilizes advanced 'Smart Tech' like autonomous drilling (reporting +51% penetration rates), these are operational efficiency tools rather than consumer-facing digital products, keeping the scoring within the standard industrial compliance range.
13
Zero Waste & Sustainable Products
-20
As a large-scale mining company, the core business involves the extraction of raw materials and the generation of significant volumes of tailings and waste rock, which inherently conflicts with circular economy principles of waste minimization and cradle-to-cradle design. First Quantum Minerals (FQM) demonstrates a robust waste management framework for a mining entity, with significant improvements in diversion and plastic reduction. In 2024, the company achieved a 65% waste diversion rate for non-mining waste (reused or recycled), up from 43% in 2023 and 33% in 2022.
1
2
3
This places them in the 'advanced waste management' tier. The company has implemented transformative single-use plastic reduction programs. Specifically, the Kansanshi mine reduced plastic bottle waste by 99.8% through reusable aluminum bottle initiatives, and across three major sites (Kansanshi, Trident, and Guelb Moghrein), plastic bottle usage has dropped by 83% since 2019.
4
Regarding waste reduction initiatives, FQM has implemented over 10 distinct programs with measurable results, including a waste oil filtration plant at Kansanshi that recycled 2 million liters of oil in 2024, the RAWMINA bioleaching project to extract materials from mine waste, and the repurposing of industrial plastics into furniture.
5
6
Hazardous waste management is focused on minimization and compliance; 46% of hazardous waste was recycled in 2023, and the company utilizes a five-level oversight system for tailings storage facilities (TSFs), aligning with the Global Industry Standard on Tailings Management (GISTM).
7
8
Compliance is strong, with the 2024 ESG report stating zero notices of violation regarding waste disposal across all operating sites and closed properties in Canada.
9
Waste audits are conducted annually for major facilities by external specialists (Engineer of Record).
10
11
While the company has quantitative targets for specific waste streams (like plastic and oil), it lacks a singular, comprehensive company-wide zero-waste-to-landfill target for all operations.
12