Summary
PDD Holdings Inc. operates two of the world's fastest-growing e-commerce platforms: Pinduoduo in China and Temu internationally. The company has over 80,000 suppliers and hundreds of millions of active users.
Our methodology scores PDD Holdings across 11 ethical dimensions. The results are severe.
| Value | Score | Grade |
|---|---|---|
| Fair Trade & Ethical Sourcing | -80 | Exploitation Enabler |
| Safe & Smart Tech | -80 | Data Violator |
| Fair Pay & Worker Respect | -60 | Labor Exploiter |
| Better Health for All | -60 | Wellness Hinderer |
| Zero Waste & Sustainable Products | -30 | Waste Creator |
Fair Trade & Ethical Sourcing: -80
PDD Holdings was excluded from Storebrand's investment portfolios in Q4 2024 due to risks related to product safety and forced labor.
The company has admitted it "does not expressly prohibit third-party sellers from selling products based on their origin in the Xinjiang Autonomous Region."
US lawmakers have warned of an "extremely high risk" that products sold on Temu have been made with forced labor. An investigation into compliance with the 2021 Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act (UFLPA) is ongoing.
Ultra Information Solutions found at least 10 items made or sold by businesses in Xinjiang available on Temu, where company links and origins are obscured.
The company does not conduct audits or publish reports on UFLPA compliance. Temu lacks transparency about its suppliers and audit results.
Germany's Federal Institute for Risk Assessment warned against jewelry containing high lead levels sold on Temu. US-based recalls highlighted dangerous toys posing choking hazards.
Safe & Smart Tech: -80
The Pinduoduo app was found to contain "invasive malware" that exploited Android vulnerabilities to gain unauthorised access to user data, including private messages.
Security researchers described it as "the most dangerous malware" ever found in a mainstream app. A team of approximately 100 engineers was dedicated to exploiting around 50 Android system vulnerabilities. The malware affected over 750 million monthly active users.
Google suspended Pinduoduo from the Play Store in March 2023 due to this malware.
Temu faces lawsuits including one from the Arkansas Attorney General (June 2024) alleging violations of privacy laws due to camera access, location tracking, and contacts collection — even overriding user privacy settings.
An Illinois class action lawsuit (November 2023) alleges data security failures and unauthorised data collection, allowing hackers to steal personal and financial information.
Temu is alleged to collect far more data than necessary, including precise location tracking, camera and microphone access, and biometric data — bypassing phone privacy settings.
Fair Pay & Worker Respect: -60
The House Select Committee on the Chinese Communist Party reported that Temu does not prohibit Xinjiang-sourced goods and lacks a meaningful compliance programme to prevent forced labor in its supply chains.
Garment workers in Southeast Asia supplying platforms like Temu typically work without employment contracts.
Two Pinduoduo employees died within a two-week period between December 2020 and January 2021, prompting official investigations.
The company relies on boilerplate terms and conditions to prohibit forced labor across its 80,000+ suppliers — with no evidence of meaningful enforcement.
Better Health for All: -60
Products sold on Temu have been found to contain illegal and toxic chemicals, defects causing electric shocks or fire hazards. Numerous items failed EU safety standards, including children's toys, cosmetics, and electric heaters.
The European Commission has opened regulatory investigations, and complaints have been filed for breaches of the Digital Services Act.
Temu's business model has been criticised for its "addictive design" potentially impacting user wellbeing, and its low prices may disproportionately expose vulnerable consumers to unsafe products.
Methodology
Every score on Mashinii is generated by analysing publicly available evidence: court filings, regulatory actions, investigative journalism, NGO reports, and company disclosures. Our scoring rubric uses defined KPIs per value dimension, with evidence cited for every claim.
This is not an opinion piece. These are findings.
Search PDD Holdings on Mashinii | View our full methodology | Audit your portfolio